A lifetime of CHs... IMHO, these are the best

[edger477]

[cmunitychest]

Great list! Exactly what I was looking for

I know most already, but there's a few new to me that I'm stoked to check out

Thanks!

[Orgentuno]

100% - YES!
For me, some of the main CH are: "ERO" series from Rinascere (Erodance and Eroclip), and all three parts of the Passion series from RedLighter. All these five works are simply a standard by which to make a classic Cock Hero! Instant classics, so to speak.

[G3TCRUNK3R]

I agree with your list about 90% - pretty close accuracy.

So I'm compelled to inform you that if you like all of these on the list, including Supermassive's Melt, then Blueberry Vortex from that same creator will change your life. Lol

Happy trails!

[smoothie69]

Incredible list! Thanks! It would be amazing if a torrent of these could be created. That would be a dream cum true!

[froog]

Agree with almost all the above. Most of those I keep going back to again and again. (from looking at most played in my library) - and also these are on my "evergreen" list:

- CH Suave by onikks
- RLGL Michelle Issizu (by digitalparkinglot) - also an estim version
- CH French Riviera by frantzo
- CH Youtube by metrognome
- Edge And Ruin Challenge and Summers Gone by Xfah and Halfx (look for the remaster by HalfX of the original)
- CH Bounce (random playlist of all the split rounds - nearly 4 hours) by mrcandyman
- CH Erocomp (megamix compilation of Erodance and Eroclip by rinascere)

[BlueM00]

The fact that numberonefan doesn't even get a mention shows how subjective these "best of" lists always are.

Would be good to have a list where anyone can add titles and their own rating, maybe also tags of content that can be filtered and sorted.

[edger477]

The fact that numberonefan doesn't even get a mention shows how subjective these "best of" lists always are.

I like numberonefan, but I don't like Cock Heros (aside from few on this list for which I created estim)... I think his work is not really in this category.

[froog]

Yeah I think the main point of this thread could be - which ones do you keep going back to again and again? Then it's clear we are not saying they are objectively the best. But still useful for some to discover new content

[smoothie69]

My favourite series is Cock Hero Island.

[drdd2000]

I haven't seen or played every last one in your list, but I have most of them, and pretty much agree.

Cock Hero of Doom and CH: Infected are in my top 5. Infected is really my #1. I took some time off and finally got through it without cheating a couple years ago. it was hard as hell, and the payoff outstanding.

CH Fail is missing from your list. Easily one of the best.

Great American Challenge by QuickX--where'd he go?!?--isn't technically a CH, but it's as good as most of these.

[chfluxfan]

Some of the best are from creators who made one masterpiece and then disappeared. CH Fail and Tinder are good examples.

AwesomeX's Remaster and Master Class are modern classics.

There's definitely a recency bias in the list, though. supermokkori's Stroker Ace and The CH Flux series stand the test of time.

[giannitrib]

Thanks for the list - appreciate the effort in collating it
I recognised many of the names - some i'm familiar with - others less so
Thought i'd have a look through to see which i had etc - i had most, managed to add a few i didn't fairly easily
And now have it as a playlist excluding the ebhan VR ones which seemed to be about 20GB+ on mega - i probably won't have the patience to download them: viewtopic.php?t=26071. I also don't have the supermassive ones - similarly they were pretty huge downloads and now not easily available - at some point i may have downloaded some of his content but i don't have any of it at the moment.
Still, the playlist is pretty epic - coming in at about 37 hours - i thought i'd give it a go in the order posted, spread over several weeks perhaps

I tend to agree that it is fairly biased to more recent releases - the earliest i can see is one of Pseudonym's from 2014 and evolution was 2015 - the rest seems to be from the 2017-2024 period

There's definitely some i would've included if i did a similar list - some of which have been mentioned - mostly older ones
But i'll give these a play, as some of them i've probably only run through once and others i haven't revisited for a while.
Curious to see whether i would rate any of them more highly, and then perhaps i might have a think through what i would come up with


[edit] Just noticed in the list of AndreX Cock Heros it mentions a beat bar version of Cock Hero Vulcan - i don't seem to have it and haven't managed to find a release thread for it. The best i could find was viewtopic.php?p=335327#p335327 which talks about it happening. I seem to remember AndreX communicated releases on twitter/X with progress updates - i haven't checked, but if there is a streaming / mega / torrent link that someone could share that would be appreciated [/edit]

[BlueM00]

The fact that numberonefan doesn't even get a mention shows how subjective these "best of" lists always are.

I like numberonefan, but I don't like Cock Heros (aside from few on this list for which I created estim)... I think his work is not really in this category.

Melt could never be mistaken for a CH :) I see that OP did indicate this was a notable exception, but that leads me to wonder if there may be other exceptions which OP has not yet encountered. NOF's Delerious Gooning Pleasure #1 or Nocturne spring to mind. Also, as I recall, Optikon Alpha had a beat-meter version, and certainly lots of requests for an encore.

I also don't particularly like CHs, as I typically find the beat-meters too distracting. Which rather proves my point about subjectivity ;)

[giannitrib]

@giannitrib: Here you go:

https://mega.nz/file/FKhh0C6I#0kJ5ifPW2 ... 5HPjbCiKiE

Much appreciated - thanks for sharing that - huge improvement on the original with the addition of the beat meter