An Edging video experiment: The Incredible Titties Test

[vivi]

Just tried it i'm afraid to say i didn't like the concept, i had to fap really fast when i was allowed and the periods were so short i only reached an edge around 20minutes in and lost it as soon as the break came, started to get good at the end though that's about it for me, i'd rather have "here you have X minutes by the end of these you will have to start edging and you will continue doing so for X minutes".

Loved the scenes and i think it's an interesting idea to have edging as the main focus.

[jared7577768]

Outstanding! It worked great, and I think your timing of the breaks is spot-on! Would love to see more of this kind of thing in the future!! Thanks!!

[supermokkori]

Just tried it i'm afraid to say i didn't like the concept, i had to fap really fast when i was allowed and the periods were so short i only reached an edge around 20minutes in and lost it as soon as the break came, started to get good at the end though that's about it for me, i'd rather have "here you have X minutes by the end of these you will have to start edging and you will continue doing so for X minutes".

Loved the scenes and i think it's an interesting idea to have edging as the main focus.

Thanks vivi for the feedback and no need to be afraid.

I was concerned about viewers " getting warmed up" properly before going all Edge happy from the start. As I stated earlier, I wouldn't do an "All Edging" video tease, but if I were to do a future tease, to add an element of Edging into a CH-type video tease, that would be the goal.

I may try to create another experimental Edging video to illustrate how I would use it - I just did this Edging experiment to see if it works for most people here.

That was really awesome! I've never really been into edging. When I jerk off, I mostly just slow down or stop when I get close, but I never make it a point to get as close to orgasm as possible. This was really hard, because my body was more or less rejecting the concept. I would try to hold the edges as long as possible, though. I'd have to say that the breaks were perfect, because later on into the video, about 20 minutes in, I would not have been able to last if I continued stimulation after edging so many times.

Either way, the results for me were great. I don't think I've blown a load like that since I was in my teens.

The clips and editing were really good. I'd like to have seen some solo stuff. Regardless, I'm sold on the concept, and I thoroughly enjoyed & appreciated the effort.

I have played through a lot of the edging teases on this site, and some are better than others, but I must say, I think you just put them out of business! Excellent work! Oh, and for those of you who are gluttons for punishment such as myself, try this out. I made my way through one of the other CH videos first, and then did this one as the "reward" video. Whew! Keep up the good work!

Outstanding! It worked great, and I think your timing of the breaks is spot-on! Would love to see more of this kind of thing in the future!! Thanks!!

Severen, jared, and jstwolf, thanks a bunch for the very kind comments. I'm curious if either of you had trouble getting to the Edge at the beginning of the video? But sounds like you both enjoyed the Edging concept here, which is a bit of a relief.

I'd like to get more feedback (and hopefully more people voting in the Poll) before I try the next Edging experiment. Thanks all again.

[Severen]

Severen, jared, and jstwolf, thanks a bunch for the very kind comments. I'm curious if either of you had trouble getting to the Edge at the beginning of the video? But sounds like you both enjoyed the Edging concept here, which is a bit of a relief.

I'd like to get more feedback (and hopefully more people voting in the Poll) before I try the next Edging experiment. Thanks all again.

I did for maybe the first 7 minutes. I just figured I'd keep stopping and going until I could edge. It wasn't really a problem for me. The only suggestion I'd make is maybe a longer warmup period for people who might need a little more time before they could edge. I'd say maybe a 10 minute warmup and then 20 minutes of continuous edging and stopping would work for me.

I can't thank you enough, though. I've always been interested in edging, but I've never really been able to do it. This is probably going to completely change the way I whack off, which is a huge feat. I came to this website for Cock Hero videos, and I'm far more into this video and the concept of edging now.

[janmb]

Torrent added (see link in my sig)

[Vinc]

please seed torrent

[wangchungass]

Mokkori

I had a tremendous orgasm at the end of round 2 but I cheated a wee bit. I couldn't keep hands off, no way that would have worked for me as I would get too soft so I just went slow during the No Stroking sections and then went fast as hell and edged at the Stoke and Edge sections.

It worked really well for me and I hope to see more, I should be able to improvise with this format.

Thanks again for the up
Regards
Wang

[316sean]

really enjoyed the video but I found it VERY hard to edge in the short time frames given, so I played every other stop and change. worked great after that.
Who is the girl at 15:00?
Who is the girl at 27:30?
Thanks again

[realnot]

Sorry man, this one just didn't work for me. I much prefer the normal CH style. As always, your video selection is excellent, but this style just didn't do it for me.

I appreciate all the hard work though!

[supermokkori]

Firstly, thanks to everyone who provided feedback and/or voted in the poll.

Going to create another "edging experiment" video over the weekend based on most of the feedback here and hopefully have it done by the weekend.

Till then, I would really like to hear feedback from those who didn't enjoy the video or didn't like/get the Edging concept. Specifically, want to know if you didn't like it because:

1) Stroking to the Edge and/or Riding the Edge was too difficult/didn't have enough time to Edge?
2) Stroking to the Edge isn't something you like in a video tease?
3) You didn't like Edging to hardcore content?
4) Other reason(s) not listed above.

Any feedback from those who didn't like the video would be appreciated.

Anyway, on to some replies:

Mokkori

I had a tremendous orgasm at the end of round 2 but I cheated a wee bit. I couldn't keep hands off, no way that would have worked for me as I would get too soft so I just went slow during the No Stroking sections and then went fast as hell and edged at the Stoke and Edge sections.

It worked really well for me and I hope to see more, I should be able to improvise with this format.

Thanks again for the up

Thanks WCA for the kind comments and good feedback.

As I stated above, I'll be working on the next "edging experiment" video over the weekend and I think I'll have a lot less "no stroking at all" periods - or at least make them a lot shorter. That seems to be the clear thing to work on based on those who liked the Edging concept.

really enjoyed the video but I found it VERY hard to edge in the short time frames given, so I played every other stop and change. worked great after that.
Who is the girl at 15:00?
Who is the girl at 27:30?

Thanks 316sean for the solid feedback. I had setup a few "short edging sessions" to see if anyone would have an issue in getting to the Edge in that short of a duration (sometimes 10 seconds). So good to get some feedback on that.

Euro pornstar Mandy Dee appears from 14:39 - 15:32 and US amateur adult star Carrie (no last alias name) appears from 27:27 - 28:25.

Sorry man, this one just didn't work for me. I much prefer the normal CH style. As always, your video selection is excellent, but this style just didn't do it for me.

Thanks realnot for the reply and feedback. I'd like to know exactly what you didn't like about the Edging concept... was it you don't like Edging or do you just like stroking to beat rhythm only? No biggie either way, just wanted to know if it's because you don't mind Edging but the system I presented didn't work or if you're just use to CH-style of stroking to a beat and this was too different. No wrong answer either way, it'll just be useful to know for my part going forward.

Thanks again everyone for participating and providing support.

[jstwolf]

Going back and looking at it again, I have to say that it probably wouldn't work well as a stand alone. Just starting from scratch, there is no way I could edge that quick. Guess I was planning ahead when I decided to use it as my reward vid. But, taken that way, it is superb. Maybe try marketing this as a hardcore winners reward video or something like that. As a matter of fact, I think I'm gonna go do that right now... only decision is which CH to warm up with....

[realnot]

Ok, some more specifics about my experience:

1. First of all, I didn't get close to the edge once, through the entire video. The time was just too short, and the "red lights" were long enough that I basically went soft by the time the next green light started. During the green lights, I'd basically just get to where I was starting to enjoy it again, and then I'd have to stop.
2. Second, even if the timing was better (and this has to be near impossible to do, since everyone is going to respond differently), I don't think I'd enjoy the concept. The long breaks generally just kind of annoy me, and I want to get back to the stroking action.
3. If I wanted to just edge a bunch of times and prolong my enjoyment, I can just do that myself (and often do). To me, the fun of the Cock Hero concept is that you're given a set requirement of what you have to do, and it's your challenge to try to control your arousal within those requirements. With this new style, I'm basically just doing whatever I want, except I'm being interrupted every once in a while.

Anyway, as I said, I appreciate the work you put into it! I don't mean to complain about something you are offering to the community for free, but I know you want honest feedback, so here is mine.

[LordAdam]

This was always going to be a difficult one to crack ... but that doesn't mean to say that it can't be cracked or that you shouldn't try.

I think this is a really great first attempt at doing something radically different to the standard CH or CH+Fetish style video.

I guess the real problem is that everyone is different in speed of response, what turns them on, what gets them to the edge and how and what keeps them there.

As such its always going to be necessary to build in quite a bit of flexibility as regards stroke style and timing -- that's not going to appeal to the strict CH fans who want a beat on rails. For them the challenge is a different one and it may be that they aren't going to be big fans of an 'edging' style game.

Personally I like the edging aspect ... my ideal CH vid is one that I can get to the edge and then stay there riding it for a long period.

As time goes by I'm sure, Mokkori, that you'll find your own groove with these vids and produce a truly great series -- I'll certainly be keeping an eye open for what you are up to!

Constructive ideas ... just a couple ... its a great idea to let folk run over the stop line so that they can reach an edge if there's not enough in the vid for them or they are slower than you thought they might be -- making the horn sound less intrusive might help them to do that (I found it a bit brash and off putting at a time when I just wanted to go a bit further!) ... some of the 'Do Not Fap' sequences seemed a bit long relative to the fapping time itself. This is probably just a personal thing and others might say the opposite.

Staying interested whilst not stroking at all, and then getting to an edge from a standing start is hard for most (me included) ... rather than a 'Do Not Fap' (total ban on stroking etc) how about a 'Stay Interested' mode where folk do what they need to keep ready to approach an edge again in a short while? That certainly works for me and gives me the best fun as I like playing with the edge when the time comes.

Anyway, great job, I'm really looking forward to your next vid!!

[Sisyphuster]

LOVED the concept, and the vids!

I concur with many people here, there wasn't enough time give to edge, and too much time "off,"
but I'm really glad you're doing these!

[dtspam]

For me, the video worked fine. I guess, one has to be horny enough (and I was really horny) to get to the edges in time. I can edge in about 10 seconds, when I'm worked up enough.
Not everyone manages to stroke as fast or long as the cockhero videos require, so maybe you should just mention how fast one should be able to edge. That way people know, if the video is for them or not.

I have a few suggestions for improvement though:
- Because the command just said "edge and hold" I was never sure how fast to edge. I think it would work better, if there would be some countdown (like edge in 10s/30s/1min).
- Most holding times were rather short for me, they could occasionally be > 1min
- The symbols for stroking and especially not stroking were kind of a turn down, at least in the beginning. (After edging enough I didn't care anymore Maybe replace them with girls (smiling and angry domme, or whatever)
- Just doing edges gets a bit repetitive. The stroking videos have more variation due to different speeds and rhythms. Maybe you could mix stroking and edging periods. Stroking fast after an edge is especially challenging after all.

I like the concept a lot. I really missed hitting or holding an edge several times during cockhero videos.
If you really get to edge during those, you most likely loose.