Game Idea: Get a 10

[CrazyTheBiker]

8

Spoiler: show

[matt264]

8

Spoiler: show

[dalin55738]

9

Spoiler: show

[matt264]

9

Spoiler: show

[hj9k1]

9

Spoiler: show

10


Congrats!
I was readying a response for the previous post and then this showed up.

[matt264]

Thank you :)

I guess round two:

Spoiler: show

[dalin55738]

(meta)
Does anyone have suggestions for how to change the game for the next round? I'm enjoying it, but wanted to see if there are some obvious ways it can be improved.

Also, I had intended on giving separate scores for each photos, so each person had 2 changes to get a 10. But since I wasn't clear in my original instructions, I just ran with it after the first response.

All suggestions welcome ;)
(/meta)

[hj9k1]

(meta)
Does anyone have suggestions for how to change the game for the next round? I'm enjoying it, but wanted to see if there are some obvious ways it can be improved.

Also, I had intended on giving separate scores for each photos, so each person had 2 changes to get a 10. But since I wasn't clear in my original instructions, I just ran with it after the first response.

All suggestions welcome ;)
(/meta)

My interpretation from what I was seeing was to post the highest score (same end result as you had in mind). Maybe that should be clarified, if people are doing the scoring differently (maybe average?).

I have some not completely thought through suggestions regarding what happens when someone wins, currently:

The winner gets 48 hours to post new images to restart the game. They can choose anything they want, whether or not they like it.

It worked out great this time that the winner came back shortly after and posted something, but the "48 hours" bit seems like it might kill the game unnecessarily if the winner is not around?

Also, maybe there could be a theme for the round or something? (Chosen by the winner? Or maybe based on the winning picture if they are not around?)

[hj9k1]

9

Spoiler: show

[matt264]

9 and 8, if we are rating both from now on, and we can set theme at the start of 3rd?

Spoiler: show

[hj9k1]

9 and 8

Spoiler: show

and we can set theme at the start of 3rd?

I'm up for it. I'd like to see what dalin55738 says about it, but I suppose we can try it regardless.

[matt264]

9 7
....we will see:P

Spoiler: show

[hj9k1]

9 and 8

Spoiler: show

[dalin55738]

I updated the rules with some of y'all's suggestions.

I like the idea of using just 1 score instead of 2. My reasoning is that we are trying to discover each others' tastes, so if we see someone gave a 9 to a curvy pawg with small tits and a tiny wasted black girl with bolted-ons, we have to guess whether they like phat asses, fake tits, bolted ons, or something else (like the angle, framing of the shot, motif of the scene, etc.) Since it's a small enough community responding, I figure we can figure each other out pretty easily. But if not, we can do 2 rankings instead of 1.

I also like the theme idea and reduced unresponsive winner's time to 2 hours (I figure that's still fair, considering the recent post times).

------------------------------------

7

Spoiler: show

[hj9k1]

7

Spoiler: show