Wow, thank you so much for your review!book_guy wrote:A good strong presentation. Not perfect, relative to my personal preferences, but right up there with all the other ones which are enjoyable enough, IMO. Will definitely be keeping an archived copy of "Cock Hero -- Island" for future ... uh ... reference and ... uh ... reconsideration.
I am not a big-tit man, generally speaking, though I won't turn them down as long as they are appealing enough. (Example: Gianna Michaels, yes sure; huge fakies bolted on to an otherwise unappealing woman, no thanks.) So I'm not the ideal target audience. But I still found this CH fun. And, the silly 1990s-style video game thing was funny, to me, and it did help string things together, so although some guys stated that they responded to it negatively, I didn't really find it a major distraction. The amoung of fapping, and the hotness of the scenes that were chosen, both are adequate to excellent, depending on which ones you're talking about. So, although this isn't the BEST CH out there for me, it's still one OF the top ones, something worth looking at again and again as time progresses.
One major comment. Personally, I don't really prefer CH videos that achieve their challenge by means of totally intense fapping, direct stimulation, as the major threat to my otherwise non-orgasmic responses. I like it when the intense fapping isn't the thing that tries to make me cum; but rather, the scenery itself, whether because it's of the right kind of chicks, because it's of the right kind of action, because it has the right mix of surprisingly sudden intensity with backing off to cause me to vamp up -- I like THAT kind of CH. Of course, it's going to be more difficult for the creator to guess what kind of chick or scene I personally prefer; therefore, the direct "fap as fast as possible forever regardless of what the imagery does for you" will always be a default value for any creator, whether he's the creator of "Island" or of any other CH. This CH does have some extended periods of rather (though, not EXTREMELY) fast stroking, and although some of the porn scenes presented were not particularly enjoyable to me during these extended periods of rather fast stroking, nevertheless the stroking was driving me closer and closer to the edge. This isn't, for me, an "ideal" arrangement. You might as well just show me the 1974 World Series game 3 pitchers' warm up, while instructing me to fap at 150 or 200 bpm, and you can probably make me cum. Heck, just record a blank image with a metronome sounding at 198 and the text-instruction "fap to the beat," and you may accomplish that. So, to me, it's not really within the theory of what CH videos are "supposed to be," which is (IMO), they are "supposed to be " stimulating because of the PORN in them and how those scenes COORDINATE with the fap instructions. Rather, this particular CH is sometimes stimulating simply because of the maximal stroking requirements. I don't mean to say that this choice HUGELY detracts from the overall experience -- I would lower its score only about 3 or 5% (so that's the difference between an A, and an A-minus, for example) for the fact of what I consider too much dependence on overt stroke-related maximal stimulation. It's really my only major complaint about this one. And anyway, there are other CH's that have much greater intensity of stroking, so it's not like it hasn't been done before. It's a choice made, not a mistake, by the creator; consequently, it DOES represent what he WANTED to do, and in that sense it's, therefore, very well done indeed. I personally would have chosen a different choice, but that's just me personally.
And a quaint aside. When I got to the end, to the "reward" round ... SPOILER ALERT ...
- Spoiler: show
The thing about the fast beats: That is SO TRUE, and SO HARD to achieve.
The thing in the spoiler button: Hahahahahaha!!! That would have been sooooo cool!!!
Would love to hear more ideas like that. I really want to make another one, not only for big boobs lovers.
