Attention for her time. Play with her breasts, stoke her legs from her feet up to her pussy, and play with her pussy and arse through her panties. Take off her panties, and lick both her pussy and arsehole so that she is really turned on and begging to be fucked.
Now apply lots of lube to her pussy and arse. Now get the butt plug, and, as with last night, put on a clean condom, lots of lube, and tease her pussy with it to start with. Insert it a little, and then take it out. Get the vibrator, and tease her with that some more. Leave it vibrating in her pussy and start to insert the butt plug into her arse. Instead of just inserting it and leaving it though, move it in and out, just a little to get her used to the movement. Leave it in, and now back to her pussy. Really torment her with the vibrator, occasionally taking the butt plug in and out slowly.
Get her close to the edge, but no cumming yet, there’s still lots more fun to be had.